I was having a discussion with a colleague last week about Unit Linked Insurance Plans. The discussion was mostly focussed towards the returns from such plans and the Mutual Funds. He was emphasising on the fact that you get both insurance coverage and market linked returns. All I told him was one line -
"Insurance is not an investment. It is expenditure."
I am going to tell you guys what ULIPs are and how do they work.Will keep it as short as possible.
What is a Unit Linked Insurance Plan (ULIP)?
A ULIP is basically a combination of insurance as well as investment. A part of the premium paid is utilized to provide insurance cover to the policy holder while the remaining portion is invested in various equity and debt schemes. The money collected by the insurance provider is utilized to form a pool of fund that is used to invest in various markets instruments (debt and equity) in varying proportions just the way it is done for mutual funds. Policy holders have the option of selecting the type of funds (debt or equity) or a mix of both based on their investment need and appetite. Just the way it is for mutual funds, ULIP policy holders are also allotted units and each unit has a net asset value (NAV) that is declared on a daily basis. The NAV is the value based on which the net rate of returns on ULIPs are determined. The NAV varies from one ULIP to another based on market conditions and the fund’s performance.
Fact - Most of us buy such products because one of our Uncles or Aunts is an insurance agent and we cannot say no to them. Has happened with me too. I am no exception.
What is the difference between a ULIP and a Mutual Fund?
Both ULIP and MFs are similar. However they are not the same. When we buy equity linked mutual fund units, our money is used to buy direct stocks. But when we buy equity-ULIP our money is used to buy mutual funds units which in turn buys stocks. So in ULIP, buying stocks is like a two step process, but in mutual fund it is a one step process. Moreover ULIP also provides insurance benefits. In addition to investment benefits ULIP provides life cover. Benefits of ULIP can be in either of the following ways:
• In case of death or maturity the insurance cover is paid to the beneficiary or,
• In case of death or maturity the fund value is paid to the beneficiary or,
• In case of death or maturity both cover and fund value is paid to the beneficiary. So before finalizing on ULIP one must ask what type of benefits it offers
• In the form of tax deductions under section 80C of the IT Act
Now that we have discussed the benefits of ULIPs, let us see the disadvantages as well -
1. In the initial few years, the costs of servicing your ULIPs are very high. They vary from 15 per cent to 65 per cent depending on the scheme and company chosen by you. What this means is that, if you invest Rs 100,000, only Rs 35,000 (65 per cent cut) to Rs 85,000 (15 per cent cut) will remain for actual investments after deducting charges
2. The cost of insurance keeps increasing every year as per your age. For example, if you are paying a mortality charge (that part of your premium that goes towards covering your life) of say Rs X when you are 30 years old, this figure can go up to Rs 2X by the time you are 40. And it keeps going up. The worst part is, since these amounts are deducted from the units, you do not see the impact of these charges on your NAV. Which is why a lot of people don't realise this happens.
3. You should read - http://www.rediff.com/getahead/2007/mar/23ulip.html
4. In any equity linked insurance product, fund management skills play a very important role. But the best fund managers in the Indian investment industry and in the world are found either working for mutual fund houses and not in insurance companies.
5. When investing in insurance, investors do not have a choice to change funds mid-way if the investments don't do well. In other investment options, investors can sell and move to a different investment.
6. Beware before you buy such bundled products (a mix of insurance and investment) like ULIPs. Ask yourself would it help if you keep your insurance and investment needs separate. While investment needs primarily seek decent returns, insurance needs are meant to protect your family or dependents in case of your death or permanent disability.
7. Remember, your insurance needs go down as your wealth increases. It helps to have a term plan that you can quit at any time without worrying too much about surrender charges and how much will you lose if you exit later. If you stop a ULIP plan in between, you pay a part of your accumulated money as charges for stopping the premiums. This is known as the 'surrender charge
Hence I would like you to focus on the following points -
1. If you want insurance, go for a term plan.
2. ULIPs can give you 12-15% returns over a longer period. However, mutual funds can give returns more than 15%.
3. There is flexibility of moving from one funds to another but that wont be the case for ULIPs.